Welcome to the Mountjoy Ministries Blog

This blog was authored by Bryan W. Sheldon, author and Bible teacher. His books are listed below. The studies in the blog are offered in the desire that they may be helpful in directing readers to the truths contained in the Bible.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

The Messiah and His Miracles (Continued)


The conflict over the oral law (1)

So, at the time of the Messiah the oral law, a binding set of rules which did not prescribe what a person must believe, only what a person must do, (sometimes called, “the tradition of the elders”), was in its second stage.  It was designed to cover every contingency of life and conduct.

The oral law is designated in the New Testament by various forms of words, some of which include the word ‘tradition’, for example, “tradition of the elders”,[1] or, “your tradition”,[2] or, the “tradition of men”.[3]  Paul, himself a Pharisee of the Pharisees, in his unregenerate state, was a zealous supporter of the oral law and he refers to it as the “traditions of my fathers”.[4] Jesus, in referring to the oral law in His teaching, used the phrase, it was said by them of old time”.[5]  This is in direct contrast to His references to the Pentateuch where He used the phrase, it is written.[6]

The difference between Rabbinism and the teachings of Christ is that Rabbinism, in practice, emphasises what a man should do, while it is concerned less over what he should believe.  Christ prescribes what a man should believe, while his conduct is largely left to his own conscience.   Rabbinism insists on works and gives liberty of faith, while Christ insists on faith and gives liberty of works.

The contrast between Jesus’ attitude to the Hebrew written scriptures, and His attitude to the ‘oral law’ is clear in the Gospels.  The evidence of the Gospel writers shows that He honoured the Hebrew Scriptures. He quoted the Pentateuch when Satan tempted Him.[7] He often quoted the prophets.[8] He acknowledged Old Testament events such as Noah and the flood,[9] Solomon and the Queen of the south,[10] Jonah and the sea creature and Jonah’s preaching at Nineveh,[11] as well as Sodom and Gomorrha.[12]  He referred to events from the first and last books of the Hebrew Scriptures - the death of Abel in Genesis and the death of Zacharias in Second Chronicles.[13]  If the definition of ‘Torah’ had been confined to the Pentateuch or even to the Hebrew written Scriptures, the Messiah would have been supportive.  He said, “Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfil”.[14]  But He was unwilling to endorse the ‘oral law’, and led opposition to it. 

As was intimated earlier, the Pharisees were the champions of the ‘oral law’.  They thought of themselves as the logical descendents of the Torah movement, begun by Ezra and continued by the ‘Hasidim’ (pious/priests) who so valiantly resisted the Hellenisation of the Jews. The Hasidim fought, often to the death, every effort of foreign invaders, to replace Hebrew culture with Greek culture. The Pharisees, in the same spirit, wished to defend any attack on the traditions for which their fathers had fought and died.  As the descendents of the Hasidim, they focused on ritual purity, calling on all households to apply the same standards of purity to the home that the priests observed in the Temple.  The Pharisees wanted to establish a kingdom of priests.  They were also very concerned with table fellowship (including dietary restrictions), Sabbath observance, tithing and circumcision.

Being guardians of the oral law, they expected Messiah to both commend them and support their work.   They reasoned that Messiah would surely expect the nation to be a law-abiding people.  However, Jesus asserted that Pharisaic legalism was external and though giving the impression that it was designed to please God was, in fact, directed towards man. It was hypocritical, and it negated both faith and love, the two basic ingredients in any relationship with God.  Jesus’s attitude to the ‘oral law’ became the focus of conflict and opposition.  When He opposed them and their doctrine, they opposed Him and His Messianic claim.

The Scribes and Pharisees, interpreters of the law, used legalism to keep power in their own hands.  However, God had never been interested in legalism. Even during Israel’s training under the Mosaic Law, the truth was ever, “the just shall live by faith”. The Talmud indicates as much.  A Talmudic passage,[15] states God gave to Moses 613 precepts, but that later seers and prophets reduced these to certain basic principles:

(1)  David reduced them to eleven,[16]Lord, who may abide in Your tabernacle? Who may dwell in Your holy hill?

(i) He who walks uprightly, (ii) And works righteousness,  (iii) And speaks the truth in his heart; (iv) He who does not backbite with his tongue, (v) Nor does evil to his neighbour, (vi) Nor does he take up a reproach against his friend; (vii) In whose eyes a vile person is despised, (viii) But he honours those who fear the Lord; (ix) He who swears to his own hurt and does not change; (x) He who does not put out his money at usury, (xi) Nor does he take a bribe against the innocent.

He who does these things shall never be moved.

(2) Isaiah reduced them to six,[17]

(i) He who walks righteously and (ii) speaks uprightly, (iii) He who despises the gain of oppressions, (iv) Who gestures with his hands, refusing bribes, (v) Who stops his ears from hearing of bloodshed, (vi) And shuts his eyes from seeing evil:

He will dwell on high; His place of defense will be the fortress of rocks; Bread will be given him, His water will be sure.

(3) Micah reduced them to three,[18] He has shown you, O man, what is good; And what does the Lord require of you

(i) But to do justly, (ii) To love mercy, (iii) And to walk humbly with your God?

(4) Habakkuk reduced them to one.[19]

“… the just shall live by his faith”.

Moreover, when the Messiah quoted the summary of the Law, the Sh’ma, He emphasised love as the key, “The first of all the commandments is: Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your mind, and with all your strength. This is the first commandment. And the second, like it, is this: You shall love your neighbour as yourself.[20]



[1] Matt.15.2; Mark 7.3,5;
[2] Matt.15.3,6; Mark 7.9,13
[3] Mark 7.8
[4] Gal.1.14
[5] Matt.5.21,27,33,43
[6] Matt.4.4,7,10
[7] Matt.4.4/Deut.8.3; Matt.4.7/Deut.6.16; Matt.4.10/Deut.6.13;10.20
[8] Matt.11.10/Mal.3.1;Isaiah.40.3; Matt.21.13/Isaiah 56.7;Jer.7.11; Matt.26.31/Zech.13.17
[9] Matt.24.37ff
[10] Matt.12.42
[11] Matt.12.39ff
[12] Matt.10.15; 11.23f
[13] Matt.23.35/Genesis to 2nd Chronicles
[14] Matt.5.17
[15] Talmud Mak.23b-24a
[16] Psalm 15
[17] Isaiah 33.15,16
[18] Micah 6.8
[19] Hab.2.4
[20] Mark 12.29-31

No comments:

Post a Comment